Laser Surgery for Vocal Cord Carcinoma Involving the Anterior Commissure

Abstract

Endoscopic laser surgery is an established means of treatment for benign laryngeal lesions. Laser surgery for early (stages I and II) squamous cell carcinoma is still being tested. Treatment of glottic tumors extending to the anterior commissure is in itself controversial. Approximately 20% of all glottic tumors involve the anterior commissure, with only 1% of these lesions being purely anterior commissure tumors. The anatomy of the anterior commissure is such that an apparent T1 lesion may actually be a T4 lesion if it involves the thyroid cartilage. The distance between the anterior commissure ligament and the thyroid cartilage is only 2 to 3 mm. A preoperative computed tomographic scan can aid us in evaluating this space. Therefore, tumors of the anterior commissure present as a therapeutic challenge. Radiation therapy has proven to be inadequate, with a high rate of recurrence and increased risk for radiochondronecrosis. The literature with regard to radiotherapy varies widely as to survival rates. Conservation surgery has consistently demonstrated an 80% survival in T1 lesions. Recently, it has been suggested that laser surgery in the region of the anterior commissure might offer satisfactory results. We have found the opposite. We will report on five patients who underwent endoscopic laser surgery on T1 vocal cord lesions involving the anterior commissure. All of these patients had tumor recurrence and subsequently have undergone salvage surgery and/or radiation therapy. The difficulties associated with endoscopic laser surgery of the anterior commissure will be discussed with a supporting animal study.