Variability of Lake Michigan water level during the past 1000 years reconstructed through optical dating of a coastal strandplain

Abstract

Post Nipissing-phase strandplains of the Great Lakes reflect late-Holocene water levels that are linked to climate variability, glacial isostasy, and changes in basin hydrology. This study examines a strandplain sequence at Bailey’s Harbor, Door County, Wisconsin, along Lake Michigan, which contains a record of water-level variations during the past 1000 years, following the separation of the Lake Michigan-Huron basin from the Lake Superior basin. Vibracores are used to define the current elevation of the foreshore facies in 25 preserved beach ridges. Optical ages for five individual beach ridges are compared with radiocarbon ages on basal peats from nine swales collected in a previous study. The optical chronology yields a ridge formation/preservation rate of 30 ± 2 yr/ridge similar to that of previous assessments. This study further demonstrates the efficacy of optical dating for deciphering late-Holocene beach-ridge sequences, providing multidecadal resolution. Lake level meets or exceeds, by at least 0.5 m, historic metrics at c. AD 1125—1225. The maximum water level after c. AD 1225 is comparable with that recorded by the instrumental data. There is a noticeable high lake level from c. AD 1560 to 1725. Dating of additional sites along Lake Michigan is required to establish local rates of glacio-isostatic adjustment, identify possible erosion of the outlets and to resolve lake-level records for individual lakes following the separation of the upper Great Lakes currently constrained to have occurred c. 2400 to 1200 years ago.