A potential need for surgeon consensus: Cementation techniques for total knee arthroplasty in orthopedic implant manufacturers’ guidelines lack consistency

Abstract

Aim: Given recent concerns regarding the influence of different cements and implants on the rate of aseptic failures in total knee arthroplasty (TKA), we wondered if cementation technique could play a role. The primary aim of this review was to collect and compare the surgeon education materials from eight orthopedic implant manufacturers to evaluate the manufacturers’ recommended cementation technique in TKA and identify if there was any consistency in these readily available guides as to the best practices of cementation of their implants. Materials and Methods: We reviewed contemporary surgeon education guidelines for all TKA systems available from eight manufacturers. Variables included: cement type, batches prepared, surface preparation prior to application, cleaning and/or drying the bone surface, mixing the cement, the waiting phase after the cement has been mixed prior to application, pressurizing the cement, location of cement application, and the curing time. Data were recorded and organized for qualitative comparisons. Results: We identified a total of 43 guides covering 38 implants from eight different manufacturers. There were 41 surgical technique guides and two general brochures regarding cementation techniques available from the manufacturers. Even within the manufacturers’ own guidelines for the different implants, there was a wide variety of differing guidelines on many aspects of the cementation technique. Conclusion: There is clearly no consensus for a preferred cementation technique both within and among manufacturers’ surgeon education materials regarding tibial baseplate cementation during TKA. Efforts may be needed to identify a best-practice cementation technique in an effort to reduce the number of TKA failures associated with aseptic loosening.