Guild Rivalries Between Barbers and Surgeons in Medieval London and England

Abstract

The origins of today’s surgical societies are the guilds of medieval London. The Company of Barbers and the Guild of Surgeons vied for dominance no different from the scores of conflicts between rival artisans and merchants whose trades overlapped. The Company dates from 1308, when the council of London passed ordinances that installed its first master, Richard le Barber. When the surgeons received ordinances of their own in 1368, the barbers had the Council reassert theirs in 1376, 1390, 1415, and 1424. Faced with a vigorous organization with greater numbers the surgeons aligned with the physicians in 1423 to form a short-lived ruling “commonalty” with an elite membership based on educational achievement and proven ability that excluded the barbers. The surgeons were thereby granted authority over all of surgery, including that practiced by barbers, an arrangement that failed after only a year. The surgeons formed a guild in 1435 but could not compete with the barbers. The barbers’ primacy became complete in 1462 when Edward IV chartered them to govern all aspects of surgery, along with the power to fine and imprison. From then barbers and surgeons amiably coexisted, likely because the rapidly growing population and the democratization of the practice of physic provided plenty of work. Henry VIII formally united the barbers and surgeons in 1540 under the Worshipful Company of Barbers and Surgeons, an amalgamation that lasted for two centuries until the surgeons broke away in 1745.