Crystal Morphology and Decalcification Patterns Compared in Rat and Human Enamel and Synthetic Hydroxyapatite

Abstract

The purpose of this investigation was to compare morphology and dissolution patterns by ultrastructural examination of rat and human enamel crystals as well as synthetic apatite crystals. Mature enamel crystals were of particular interest, since crystal maturation appears to be inhibited in amelogenesis imperfecta. Specimens were isolated from developing and mature rat incisor enamel. Rat enamel, mature human enamel, and synthetic apatite were thin-sectioned without decalcification and examined by transmission electron microscopy. Some sections were exposed to acid, and selected synthetic apatite sections were further treated for removal of embedding plastic, followed by vacuum-shadow-coating with carbon. Results showed that cross-sections of rat, human, and synthetic crystals had a distortion in the flattened hexagonal outline in regions where the growth of one crystal impinged on another. Crystal dissolution occurred preferentially along the c-axis, producing a central defect or hole in the crystals. Preliminary studies with weak acid on mature human enamel indicate that the relatively soluble crystal core is quickly dissolved, while the outer shell remains intact over a much longer period of time. In the mature rat and human enamel, this crystal hole formation had a consistent dimension of approximately 10-nm thickness. The crystal hole dimension was the same size as crystals that are formed during the early secretory phase in rat amelogenesis. Acid-treated synthetic apatite also showed dissolution of the crystal core along the c-axis, but dimensions of the hole were not consistent. Shadowed grids showed that the defective hole penetrated the entire section thickness. Mature human enamel showed a unique variation to acid at rod borders where larger, isohexagonal crystals were resistant to acid dissolution. It was concluded that (1) crystals of rat and human enamel show evidence of diphasic growth that may affect their dissolution properties, and (2) unique acid-resistant crystals in human enamel at rod borders may be a result of long oral exposure.