We investigate the question of which finite lattices
L
L
are isomorphic to the lattice
[
H
,
G
]
[H,G]
of all overgroups of a subgroup
H
H
in a finite group
G
G
. We show that the structure of
G
G
is highly restricted if
[
H
,
G
]
[H,G]
is disconnected. We define the notion of a “signalizer lattice" in
H
H
and show for suitable disconnected lattices
L
L
, if
[
H
,
G
]
[H,G]
is minimal subject to being isomorphic to
L
L
or its dual, then either
G
G
is almost simple or
H
H
admits a signalizer lattice isomorphic to
L
L
or its dual. We use this theory to answer a question in functional analysis raised by Watatani.