The Impact of Perceived Upper Extremity Severity and Prior Surgery on Patient-Reported Outcomes

Abstract

Background: The recently validated Hand Questionnaire (HAND-Q) is a multifaceted patient-reported outcome measure (PROM) for hand/upper extremity (UE) pathology and treatment. Here, we conduct a pilot study utilising data collected as a participating site for the Phase II HAND-Q Pilot Multicenter International Validation Study. We hypothesised that self-reported hand functionality, symptom/disease severity, hand appearance, emotional dissatisfaction and treatment satisfaction would be worse in patients who perceived their disease severity to be more severe but would not differ between patients based on prior surgical history. Methods: Patients were prospectively enrolled for HAND-Q participation from September 2018 to August 2019. Patients were included in this analysis if they responded to the following scales of HAND-Q: Hand Functionality Satisfaction, Symptom Severity, Hand Appearance Satisfaction, Emotional Dissatisfaction and Treatment Satisfaction. Composite scores (CS) were created for each section. Surgical versus non-surgical CS and mild versus moderate/severe CS were compared with t-tests. Bi-variate comparisons of responses were performed between surgical and non-surgical groups, and between mild and moderate/severe groups. Results: HAND-Q individual question analysis revealed significant differences in functionality and symptom severity for patients with prior surgery (p < 0.047). CS analysis confirmed greater overall impairment in surgical patients, but no overall impact on symptom severity. Regarding disease severity HAND-Q individual question analysis, moderate/severe patients reported worse outcomes for specific aesthetic qualities and symptoms for almost all items (p < 0.05). CS analysis revealed significantly worse overall hand appearance satisfaction, hand functionality, emotional satisfaction and symptom severity for patients with moderate/severe hand conditions. Conclusions: HAND-Q revealed worsened outcomes for UE patients with self-reported moderate/severe conditions or previous surgical history. Understanding how previous surgery and disease severity may impact clinical outcomes is important for crafting appropriate treatment. Level of Evidence: Level II (Prognostic Study)