Profiling serum immunodominance following SARS-CoV-2 primary and breakthrough infection reveals distinct variant-specific epitope usage and immune imprinting

Abstract

AbstractOver the course of the COVID-19 pandemic, variants have emerged with increased mutations and immune evasive capabilities. This has led to breakthrough infections (BTI) in vaccinated individuals, with a large proportion of the neutralizing antibody response targeting the receptor binding domain (RBD) of the SARS-CoV-2 Spike glycoprotein. Immune imprinting, where prior exposure of an antigen to the immune system can influence the response to subsequent exposures, and its role in a population with heterogenous exposure histories has important implications in future vaccine design. Here, we develop an accessible approach to map epitope immunodominance of the neutralizing antibody response in sera. By using a panel of mutant Spike in a pseudovirus neutralization assay, we observed distinct epitope usage in convalescent donors infected during wave 1, or infected with the Delta, or BA.1 variants, highlighting the antigenic diversity of the variant Spikes. Analysis of longitudinal serum samples taken spanning 3 doses of vaccine and subsequent breakthrough infection (BTI), showed the influence of immune imprinting from the ancestral-based vaccine, where reactivation of existing B cells elicited by the vaccine resulted in the enrichment of the pre-existing epitope immunodominance. However, subtle shifts in epitope usage in sera were observed following BTI by Omicron sub-lineage variants. Antigenic distance of Spike, time after last exposure, and number of vaccine boosters may play a role in the persistence of imprinting from the vaccine. This study provides insight into RBD neutralizing epitope usage in individuals with varying exposure histories and has implications for design of future SARS-CoV-2 vaccines.Author SummaryThroughout the COVID-19 pandemic, the continued emergence of new SARS-CoV-2 variants has resulted in a rise in breakthrough infections (BTIs). Infection with different variants has led to varying exposure histories in the general population. Although the neutralizing response to Spike has been thoroughly characterized, with several key epitopes identified, there is a lack of knowledge of the proportion each epitope contributes to the neutralizing response in sera and how this is affected by exposure history. Here, we use a panel of mutant Spike pseudoviruses to screen epitope usage and immunodominance in polyclonal sera. In a cohort of unvaccinated donors infected with different variants, distinct epitope usage was observed, highlighting the antigenic diversity between the variant Spikes. Furthermore, samples collected spanning multiple vaccine doses and BTI showed the influence of prior immunity from the vaccine on epitope usage. Although a large proportion of the immune response following BTI could be attributed to enrichment of pre-existing immunodominance from the vaccine, subtle shifts in epitope usage were observed with infection by more mutated variants. This work gives more detailed insight into differences in the neutralizing response of individuals with varying exposure histories that may inform next generation SARS-CoV-2 vaccines.