Supervised Promoter Recognition: A benchmark framework

Abstract

AbstractDeep learning has become a prevalent method in identifying genomic regulatory sequences such as promoters. In a number of recent papers, the performance of deep learning models have continually been reported as an improvement over alternatives for sequence-based promoter recognition. However, the performance improvements in these models do not account for the different datasets that models are being evaluated on. The lack of a consensus dataset and procedure for benchmarking purposes has made the comparison of each model’s true performance difficult to assess.We present a framework called Supervised Promoter Recognition Framework (‘SUPR REF’) capable of streamlining the complete process of training, validating, testing, and comparing promoter recognition models in a systematic manner. SUPR REF includes the creation of biologically relevant benchmark datasets to be used in the evaluation process of deep learning promoter recognition models. We showcase this framework by comparing the models’ performance on alternative datasets, and properly evaluate previously published models on new benchmark datasets. Our results show that the reliability of deep learning ab initio promoter recognition models on eukaryotic genomic sequences is still not at a sufficient level, as precision is severely lacking. Furthermore, given the observational nature of these data, cross-validation results from small datasets need to be interpreted with caution.AvailabilitySource code and documentation of the framework is available online at https://github.com/ivanpmartell/suprref