Broadly-reactive IgG responses to heterologous H5 prime-boost influenza vaccination are shaped by antigenic relatedness to priming strains

Abstract

ABSTRACTPrime-boost vaccinations of humans with different H5 strains have generated broadly protective antibody levels. However, the effect of an individual’s H5 exposure history on antibody responses to subsequent H5 vaccination is poorly understood. To investigate this, we analyzed the IgG response to H5 A/Indonesia/5/2005 (Ind05) vaccination in three cohorts: (1) a double primed group that received two H5 vaccinations: A/Vietnam/203/2004 (Vie04) 5 years ago and A/Hong Kong/156/1997 (HK97) 11 years ago, (2) a single primed group that received Vie04 5 years ago, and (3) an H5-naïve group that received two doses of the Ind05 vaccine 28 days apart. Hemagglutinin (HA)-reactive IgG levels were estimated by multiplex assay against an HA panel that included 21 H5 strains and 9 other strains representing H1, H3, H7, and H9 subtypes. Relative HA antibody landscapes were generated to quantitatively analyze the magnitude and breadth of antibody binding after vaccination. We found that short-interval prime-boosting with the Ind05 in the naïve group generated a low anti-H5 response. Both primed groups generated robust antibody responses reactive to a broad range of H5 strains after boosting with Ind05; IgG antibody levels persisted longer in subjects who had been double primed years ago. Notably, the IgG responses were strongest against the first priming H5 strain, that reflecting influenza virus immune imprinting. Finally, the broad anti-H5 IgG response was stronger against strains having a small antigenic distance to the initial priming strain.IMPORTANCEThe antigenic shift and draft of hemagglutinin (HA) in influenza viruses is accepted as one of the major reasons for immune evasion. The analysis of B cell immune responses to influenza infection and vaccination is complicated by the impact of exposure history and antibody cross-reaction between antigenically similar influenza strains. To assist in such analyses, the influenza “antibody landscape” method has been used to analyze and visualize the relationship of antibody mediated immunity to the antigenic distance between influenza strains. In this study, we describe a “relative antibody landscape” method, calculating the antigenic distance between the vaccine influenza strain and other H5 strains, and using this relative antigenic distance to plot with the anti-H5 IgG levels post-vaccination. This new method quantitatively estimates and visualizes the correlation between the humoral response to a particular influenza strain, and the antigenic distance to other strains. Our findings demonstrate the effect of H5 exposure history on H5 vaccine responses quantified by the relative antibody landscape method.