Delayed but generalist resistance in alternation: a trade-off shaped by the mode of action of antifungals, as revealed by experimental evolution in a plant pathogen

Abstract

AbstractThe evolution of resistance to pesticides is a major burden in agriculture. Resistance management involves maximizing selection pressure heterogeneity, particularly by combining active ingredients with different modes of action. We tested the hypothesis that the temporal alternation of active ingredients may delay the build-up of resistance not only by spreading selection pressure over longer periods, but also by decreasing the rate of evolution of resistance to alternated fungicides. Here, we applied an original experimental evolution approach to the economically important crop pathogen Zymoseptoria tritici. We observed the dynamics of Z. tritici resistance in 56 independent lines subjected to 14 continuous or alternation regimes of 3 fungicides contrasting for their mode of action, at their EC95 selection doses. For the first time in a plant pathogen, our results show that alternation is either neutral or slows the evolution of resistance, relative to continuous fungicide use, but results in higher levels of generalism in evolved lines. We demonstrate that the mode of action of resistance of fungicides drivingly underlies this trade-off, more so than the number of fungicides and the frequency of alternation. This trade-off is also dynamic over the course of resistance evolution, as shown by the change in population phenotype structure and the relative impact of selection drivers. These findings open up new possibilities for tailoring resistance management effectively while optimizing smart interplay between alternation components. They also confirm experimental evolution as an untapped but promising approach to dissect adaptation in phytopathogenic fungi.Author summaryThe efficacy of pesticides has been compromised by the generalization of their use, leading to the rapid and widespread evolution of resistance. This constitutes a major economic and environmental burden in agriculture. The temporal alternation (or cycling) of active ingredients is a management strategy that induces temporal variation of selection of pathogens. Here, we dissected how it can be optimized according to the number and nature of alternated modes of action and to the rhythm of their application and sought to understand how these drivers determine the performance of alternation strategies. We used an approach original in plant pathology, experimental evolution, applied on an economically important fungus, Zymoseptoria tritici. We concluded that alternation can delay the rate of resistance selection with performance depending most likely on the mode of action of alternated antifungals, more so than on other drivers. But we also highlighted that alternation regimes select generalist resistance, that is the ability to resist a large diversity of antifungals. This trade-off was dynamic over time. Our study provides new insights for the informed management of pesticides and the reduction of their side effects.