A cautionary tale on proper use of branch-site models to detect convergent positive selection

Abstract

AbstractComparative genomics has become a powerful tool to elucidate genotype-phenotype relationships, particularly through the study of convergently acquired phenotypes. By identifying genes under positive selection specifically on branches with the convergent phenotype we can potentially link genes to that phenotype. Such gene scans are often done using branch-site codon models. However, we have observed a recent troubling trend of misinterpretation of branch-site models in which phylogeny-wide positive selection is not distinguished from positive selection specific to convergent branches. Here, we use simulations and real data to demonstrate how failing to discern between these two cases leads to false inferences of positive selection associated with a convergent trait. We then present a “ drop-out” test solution to distinguish the two cases and thereby truly capture positive selection events associated with convergent phenotypes, thus allowing for further insights into both genetic and phenotypic evolution.