Higher-order effects, continuous species interactions, and trait evolution shape microbial spatial dynamics

Abstract

AbstractThe assembly and maintenance of microbial diversity in natural communities, despite the abundance of toxin-based antagonistic interactions, presents major challenges for biological understanding. A common framework for investigating such antagonistic interactions involve cyclic dominance games with pairwise interactions. The incorporation of higher-order interactions in such models permits increased levels of microbial diversity, especially in communities where antibiotic producing, sensitive, and resistant strains co-exist. However, most such models involve a small number of discrete species, assume a notion of pure cyclic dominance, and focus on low mutation rate regimes, none of which well represents the highly interlinked, quickly evolving, and continuous nature of microbial phenotypic space. Here, we present an alternative vision of spatial dynamics for microbial communities based on antagonistic interactions—one in which a large number of species interact in continuous phenotypic space, are capable of rapid mutation, and engage in both direct and higher-order interactions mediated by production of and resistance to antibiotics. Focusing on toxin production, vulnerability, and inhibition among species, we observe highly divergent patterns of diversity and spatial community dynamics. We find that species interaction constraints (rather than mobility) best predict spatiotemporal disturbance regimes, whereas community formation time, mobility, and mutation size best explain patterns of diversity. We also report an intriguing relationship among community formation time, spatial disturbance regimes, and diversity dynamics. This relationship, which suggests that both higher-order interactions and rapid evolution are critical for the origin and maintenance of microbial diversity, has broad-ranging links to the maintenance of diversity in other systems.Significance StatementPersistently diverse microbial communities are one of biology’s great puzzles. Using a novel continuous trait space modeling framework that accommodates high mutation rates, elevated species richness, and direct and higher-order antagonistic species interactions, we find that two parameters characterizing mutation size and mobility best explain patterns of microbial diversity. Moreover, community formation time (the duration of the transient phase in community assembly) provides an unexpectedly clear guide to the diversity profiles of the resulting communities. These discoveries showcase how complex, antagonistic interactions mediated by the production of, inhibition of, and vulnerability to toxins (antibiotics) can shape microbial communities, allowing for extraordinarily high levels of diversity and temporal persistence.