A Model Mechanism Based Explanation of an In Vitro-In Vivo Disconnect for Improving Extrapolation and Translation

Abstract

AbstractAn improved understanding of in vivo-to-in vitro hepatocyte changes is crucial to interpreting in vitro data correctly and further improving hepatocyte-based in vitro-to-in vivo extrapolations to human targets. We demonstrate using virtual experiments as a means to help untangle plausible causes of inaccurate extrapolations. We start with virtual mice that have biomimetic software livers. Earlier, using those mice, we discovered model mechanisms that enabled achieving quantitative validation targets while also providing plausible causal explanations for temporal characteristics of acetaminophen hepatotoxicity. We isolated virtual hepatocytes, created a virtual culture, and then conducted dose-response experiments in both culture and mice. We expected the two dose-response curves to be displaced. We were surprised that they crossed because it evidenced that simulated acetaminophen metabolism and toxicity are different for virtual culture and mouse contexts even though individual hepatocyte mechanisms were unchanged. Crossing dose-response curves is a virtual example of an in vivo-to-in vitro disconnect. We use detailed results of experiments to explain the disconnect. Individual hepatocytes contribute differently to system level phenomena. In liver, hepatocytes are exposed to acetaminophen sequentially. Relative production of the reactive acetaminophen metabolite is largest (smallest) in pericentral (periportal) hepatocytes. Because that sequential exposure is absent in culture, hepatocytes from different lobular locations do not respond the same. A virtual Culture-to-Mouse translation can stand as a scientifically challengeable theory explaining an in vitro-in vivo disconnect. It provides a framework to develop more reliable interpretations of in vitro observations, which then may be used to improve extrapolations.AbbreviationsaHPCanalog hepatocyteAPAPacetaminophenCVCentral VeinSSsinusoidal segmentNAPQIN-acetyl-p-benzoquinone iminemitoDmitochondrial damage productsnonMDnon-mitochondrial damage products