Sexual conflict promotes species coexistence through negative frequency dependence

Abstract

AbstractA major challenge in community ecology is to understand the mechanisms promoting stable local coexistence. A necessary feature of local coexistence is that species show negative frequency dependence, rescuing rare species from exclusion. However, most studies have focused on ecological differences driving negative frequency dependence, ignoring non-ecological mechanisms such as reproductive interactions. Here, we combined field studies with behavioural and mesocosm experiments to investigate how reproductive interactions within and between species promote coexistence. Our results indicate that the intensity of male mating harassment and sexual conflict increases as species become more common, reducing female productivity and leading to negative frequency dependence. Moreover, field surveys reveal that negative frequency dependence operates in natural settings, consistent with our experimental results. These results suggest that sexual conflict can promote local coexistence and highlights the importance of studying reproductive interactions together with ecological differences to better understand the mechanisms promoting species coexistence.Significance statementResearch on the mechanisms promoting local species coexistence have focused on canonical ecological differences that increase intraspecific over interspecific competition. However, one intrinsic factor of species that can promote coexistence are the reproductive interactions. We performed a series of behavioural and mesocosm experiments manipulating species frequencies together with field observations and show that sexual conflict can decrease female fitness when species are common and promote local coexistence. Our results suggest that reproductive interactions are an understudied mechanism that can promote species coexistence even when species are ecologically equivalent.