Author:
Bhuiyan Shamsuddin A.,Ly Sophia,Phan Minh,Huntington Brandon,Hogan Ellie,Liu Chao Chun,Liu James,Pavlidis Paul
Abstract
ABSTRACTAlthough most mammalian genes have multiple isoforms, an ongoing debate is whether these isoforms are all functional as well as the extent to which they increase the genome’s functional repertoire. To ground this debate in data, we established a curation framework for evaluating experimental evidence of functionally distinct splice isoforms (FDSIs) and analyzed splice isoform function for over 700 human and mouse genes. Despite our bias towards prominently studied genes, we found experimental evidence meeting the classical definition for functionally distinct isoforms for only ~5% of the curated genes. If we relax our criteria, the fraction of genes with support for FDSIs remains low (~13%). We provide evidence that this picture will not change substantially with further curation. Furthermore, many FDSIs did not trace to a specific isoform in Ensembl. Our work has implications for computational analyses of alternative splicing and should help shape research around the role of splicing on gene function from presuming large general effects to acknowledging the need for stronger experimental evidence.
Publisher
Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory
Reference53 articles.
1. Alternatively Spliced Homologous Exons Have Ancient Origins and Are Highly Expressed at the Protein Level
2. Alternative splicing and co-option of transposable elements: the case of TMPO/LAP2α and ZNF451 in mammals
3. Aken BL , Ayling S , Barrell D , Clarke L , Curwen V , Fairley S , Banet JF , Billis K , Girón CG , Hourlier T , Howe K , Kähäri A , Kokocinski F , Martin FJ , Murphy DN , Nag R , Ruffier M , Schuster M , Tang YA , Vogel J-H , et al (2016) The Ensembl gene annotation system. Database 2016: baw093
4. Alberts B , Johnson A , Lewis J , Raff M , Roberts K & Walter P (2002) Studying Gene Expression and Function. Available at: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK26818/ [Accessed April 19, 2017]
5. Alternative mRNA processing sites decrease genetic variability while increasing functional diversity;Transcription,2018