Measurement error and variant-calling in deep Illumina sequencing of HIV

Abstract

ABSTRACTMotivationNext-generation deep sequencing of viral genomes, particularly on the Illumina platform, is increasingly applied in HIV research. Yet, there is no standard protocol or method used by the research community to account for measurement errors that arise during sample preparation and sequencing. Correctly calling high and low frequency variants while controlling for erroneous variant calls is an important precursor to downstream interpretation, such as studying the emergence of HIV drug-resistance mutations, which in turn has clinical applications and can improve patient care.ResultsWe developed a new variant-calling pipeline, hivmmer, for Illumina sequences from HIV viral genomes. First, we validated hivmmer by comparing it to other variant-calling pipelines on real HIV plasmid data sets, which have known sequences. We found that hivmmer achieves a lower rate of erroneous variant calls, and that all methods agree on the frequency of correctly called variants. Next, we compared the methods on an HIV plasmid data set that was sequenced using an amplicon-tagging protocol called Primer ID, which is designed to reduce errors and amplification bias during library preparation. We show that the Primer ID consensus does indeed have fewer erroneous variant calls compared to the variant-calling pipelines, and that hivmmer more closely approaches this low error rate compared to the other pipelines. Surprisingly, the frequency estimates from the Primer ID consensus do not differ significantly from those of the variant-calling pipelines. Finally, we built a predictive model for classifying errors in the hivmmer alignment, and show that it achieves high accuracy for identifying erroneous variant calls.Availabilityhivmmer is freely available for non-commercial use from https://github.com/mhowison/hivmmer.Contactmhowison@brown.edu