Dissociation of novel open loop from ventral putamen to motor areas from classic closed loop in humans II: task-based function

Abstract

AbstractHumans ubiquitously increase the speed of their movements when motivated by incentives (i.e., capturing reward or avoiding loss). The complex interplay between incentivization and motor output is pertinent for unpacking the functional profiles of different circuits that link the basal ganglia with motor cortical areas. Here, we analyzed the functional profile of nodes forming two circuits involving putamen and motor cortical areas: the traditional “closed-loop circuit” (CLC) from sensorimotor dorsal putamen (PUTd) and a putative “open-loop circuit” (OLC) from ventral putamen (PUTv). Establishing differential function between CLC and OLC is particularly relevant for therapeutic approaches to Parkinson’s disease, where OLC function is hypothesized to be relatively spared by the disease process. In a large sample fMRI study, 68 healthy controls executed speeded reaches with a joystick under different levels of incentivization to accurately hit precision targets. We dissociated effects of “incentive per se” (i.e., changes in brain activity when an upcoming movement obtains a reward or avoids a loss) from “RT effects” (i.e., brain activity that directly scales with adjustments to movement initiation time). Incentive per se was observed across sites in both CLC and OLC. However, RT effects were primarily in nodes of the OLC and motor sites, consistent with the hypothesized anatomy and function of OLC. Our findings additionally suggest valence might mediate when incentives recruit OLC to more prominent control of motor behavior.