Recording site placement on planar silicon-based probes affects neural signal quality: edge sites enhance acute recording performance

Abstract

AbstractObjectiveMultisite, silicon-based probes are widely used tools to record the electrical activity of neuronal populations. Several physical features of these devices (e.g. shank thickness, tip geometry) are designed to improve their recording performance. Here, our goal was to investigate whether the position of recording sites on the silicon shank might affect the quality of the recorded neural signal in acute experiments.ApproachNeural recordings obtained with five different types of high-density, single-shank, planar silicon probes from anesthetized rats were analyzed. Wideband data were filtered (500 - 5000 Hz) to extract spiking activity, then various quantitative properties (e.g. amplitude distribution of the filtered potential, single unit yield) of the recorded cortical and thalamic activity were compared between sites located at different positions of the silicon shank, focusing particularly on edge and center sites.Main resultsEdge sites outperformed center sites: mean values of the examined properties of the spiking activity were in most cases higher for edge sites (~94%, 33/35) and a large fraction of these differences were also statistically significant (~45%, 15/33) with effect sizes ranging from small to large. Although the single unit yield was similar between site positions, the difference in signal quality was remarkable in the range corresponding to high-amplitude spikes. Furthermore, the advantage of edge sites slightly decreased for probes having a narrower shank.SignificanceThe better signal quality on edge sites might be the result of the reduced shielding effect of the silicon shank providing a larger field of view for edge sites to detect spikes, or the less tissue damage caused near the edges of the shank. Our results might aid the design of novel neural implants in enhancing their recording performance by identifying more efficient recording site placements.