Is sobriety from alcohol necessary for evaluation of patients presenting with suicidal ideation?

Abstract

BackgroundIt is commonly assumed that patients intoxicated with alcohol are unreliable with respect to their statements of suicidal intent, however no prior literature evaluates the impact of sobriety on suicidal ideation (SI). In typical emergency department (ED) settings, a common practice is to wait until intoxicated suicidal individuals have reached a legally sober limit (ethanol level less than 80 mg/dL) to evaluate safety. We are not aware of any study that establishes the diagnostic reliability of the clinical suicidal ideation evaluation as a function of alcohol intoxication.MethodsThis study is a retrospective review of medical records for patients evaluated in a pre-COVID Midwestern ED for one calendar year. Cases were generated for review based on criteria of having a Psychiatric SW (Social Work) consult and blood alcohol level drawn while in the ED on every Wednesday and Friday of 2017 which produced 1084 cases for review. Chi-square analysis was used for comparison of variables of suicidal ideation with or without alcohol intoxication as defined by blood alcohol level (BAL) ≥80 mg/dL.ResultsIn reference to our initial hypothesis, patients presenting with suicidal ideation and concurrent alcohol intoxication were no longer reporting suicidal ideation at sobriety in 69% of cases, compared to 38% for patients without alcohol levels on presentation. Chi-square analysis demonstrated p=0.000012.ConclusionThe goal of the present study was to demonstrate, with empirical data, a relationship between alcohol intoxication and suicidal ideation. Our data suggests that patients presenting to the ED with complaints related to suicidal behavior who are found to have concurrent alcohol intoxication are more likely to deny suicidal ideation when sober than patients with similar presenting complaints and no alcohol intoxication.