Patterns of parent and offspring gene expression reflect canalization, not plasticity, in response to environmental stress

Abstract

ABSTRACTParenting buffers offspring from hostile environments, but it is not clear how or if the genes that underlie parenting change their expression under environmental stress. We recently demonstrated that for the subsocial carrion beetle, Nicrophorus orbicollis, temperature during parenting does not affect parenting phenotypes. Here, we ask if transcriptional changes associated with parenting are likewise robust to environmental stress. The absence of a transcriptional response for parenting under stress would suggest that the genetic ‘programs’ for parenting and being parented are canalized. Conversely, a robust transcriptional response would suggest that plasticity of underlying gene expression is critical for maintaining behavioral stability, and that these mechanisms provide a potential target for selection in the face of environmental change. We test these alternatives by characterizing gene expression of parents and offspring with and without parent-offspring interactions under a benign and a stressful temperature. We found that parent-offspring interactions elicit distinct transcriptional responses of parents and larvae irrespective of temperature. We further detected robust changes of gene expression in beetles breeding at 24° C compared to 20° C irrespective of family interaction. However, no strong interaction between parent-offspring interaction and temperature was detected for either parents or larvae. We therefore conclude that canalization, not plasticity of gene expression, most likely explains the absence of behavioral plasticity under thermal stress. This result suggests that species may not have the genetic variation needed to respond to all environmental change, especially for complex phenotypes.IMPACT STATEMENTParenting is thought to evolve to buffer offspring from harsh or inhospitable conditions. However, once evolved, does parenting continue to buffer against new environmental challenges such as might occur under global warming? One way organisms achieve different phenotypes without evolving different genes for each trait is by changing timing or extent of gene expression. Changes in gene expression influencing physiological traits such as hypoxia have been shown to facilitate adaptation to changing environments. It is less clear if changes in gene expression are also important for behavioral plasticity in complex social traits, such as parental care. In this study, we ask whether families of the subsocial burying beetle, Nicrophorus orbicollis, show altered expression of parent or offspring genes that may help compensate for reduced offspring success under global warming. To test the extent that gene expression underlies behavioral plasticity in parenting and offspring responses to parenting, we characterize the gene expression profiles of whole families (males, females, and larvae) with and without parent-offspring interactions under two thermal conditions: 20° C and 24° C. We found that heat stress predominantly induced downregulation of genes, consistent with a constrained acclimation response. However, when temperature was considered in conjunction with parent-offspring interactions, genetic plasticity was extremely limited. That is, the genes underlying parent-offspring interactions did not show strong signatures of differential expression under more stressful thermal conditions. Given that we previously found no effects of temperature on parental behavior, we suggest that constrained, not plastic gene expression, underpins stability of parent-offspring interactions and limits the buffering capacity for family interactions under environmental stress. Insights from this study deepen our understanding of the interplay between genetic and phenotypic plasticity in complex behavioral traits and how traits such as parenting may limit responses to novel environmental challenges.