Large-scale analyses reveal the contribution of adaptive evolution in pathogenic and non-pathogenic fungal species

Abstract

AbstractGenome studies of fungal pathogens have presented evidence for exceptionally high rates of evolution. It has been proposed that rapid adaptation is a hallmark of pathogen evolution that facilitates the invasion of new host niches and the overcoming of intervention strategies such as fungicide applications and drug treatments. To which extent high levels of genetic variation within and between species correlate with adaptive protein evolution in fungi more generally has so far not been explored. In this study, we addressed the contribution of adaptive evolution relative to genetic drift in 20 fungal species, hereby exploring genetic variation in 2,478 fungal genomes. We reannotated positions of protein-coding genes to obtain a high-quality dataset of 234,427 full-length core gene and 25,612 accessory gene alignments. We applied an extension of the McDonald-Kreitman test that models the distributions of fitness effects to infer the rate of adaptive (ωA) and non-adaptive (ωNA) non-synonymous substitutions in protein-coding genes. To explore the relevance of recombination on local adaptation rates, we inferred the population genomic recombination rate for all 20 species. Our analyses reveal extensive variation in rates of adaptation and show that high rates of adaptation are not a hallmark of a pathogenic lifestyle. Up to 83% of non-synonymous substitutions are adaptive in the speciesParastagonospora nodorum. However, non-synonymous substitutions in other species, including the prominent rice-infecting pathogenMagnaporthe oryzae, are predominantly non-adaptive (neutral or slightly deleterious). Correlating adaptation measures with effective population size and recombination rate, we show that effective population size is a primary determinant of adaptive evolution in fungi. At the genome scale, recombination rate variation explains variation in both ωAand ωNA. Finally, we demonstrate the robustness of our estimates using simulations. We underline the value of population genetic principles in studies of fungal evolution, and we highlight the importance of demographic processes in adaptive evolution of pathogenic and non-pathogenic species.