The Creation of a Multidomain Neighborhood Environmental Vulnerability Index Across an Urban Center

Abstract

ABSTRACTCompared to previous studies that have typically used a single summary score, we aimed to construct a multidomain neighborhood environmental vulnerability index (NEVI) to characterize the magnitude and variability of area-level factors with the potential to modify the health effects of environmental pollutants. Using the Toxicological Prioritization Index framework and data from the 2015-2019 U.S. Census American Community Survey and the 2020 CDC PLACES Project, we quantified census tract-level vulnerability overall and in 4 primary domains (demographic, economic, residential, and health status), 24 subdomains, and 54 distinct area-level features for New York City (NYC). Overall and domain-specific indices were calculated by summing standardized feature values within the subdomains and then aggregating and weighting subdomains within equally-weighted primary domains. In citywide comparisons, NEVI was correlated with both the Neighborhood Deprivation Index (r = 0.91) and the Social Vulnerability Index (r = 0.87) but provided additional information on features contributing to vulnerability. Vulnerability varied spatially across NYC, and hierarchical cluster analysis using subdomain scores revealed six patterns of vulnerability across domains: 1) low in all, 2) primarily low except residential, 3) medium in all, 4) high demographic, economic, and residential 5) high economic, residential, and health status, and 6) high demographic, economic and health status. Created using a tool that offers flexibility for theory-based construction, NEVI provided detailed metrics of vulnerability across domains that can inform targeted research and public health interventions aimed at reducing the health impacts from environmental exposures across an urban center.