Priors for natural image statistics inform confidence in perceptual decisions

Abstract

AbstractDecision confidence plays a critical role in humans’ ability to make adaptive decisions in a noisy perceptual world. Despite its importance, there is currently little consensus about the computations underlying confidence judgements in perceptual decisions. In order to better understand these mechanisms, in this study we sought to address the extent to which confidence is informed by a naturalistic prior probability distribution. Contrary to previous research, we did not require participants to internalise the parameters of an arbitrary prior distribution. Instead we used a novel psychophysical paradigm which allowed us to capitalise on probability distributions of low-level image features in natural scenes, which are well-known to influence perception. Participants reported the subjective upright of naturalistic image target patches, and then reported their confidence in their orientation responses. We used computational modelling to relate the statistics of the low-level features in the targets to the distribution of these features across many natural images. As expected, we found that participants used an internalised prior of the regularities of low-level natural image statistics to inform their perceptual judgements. Critically, we also show that the same low-level image statistics predict participants’ confidence judgements. Overall, our study highlights the importance of using naturalistic task designs that capitalise on existing, long-term priors to further our understanding of the computational basis of confidence.