Short-distance gene flow and morphological divergence in Eschscholzia parishii (Papaveraceae): implications for speciation in desert winter annuals

Abstract

Abstract Winter annuals comprise a large fraction of warm-desert plant species, but the drivers of their diversity are little understood. One factor that has generally been overlooked is the lack of obvious means of long-distance seed dispersal in many desert-annual lineages, which could lead to genetic differentiation at small spatial scales and, ultimately, to speciation and narrow endemism. If our gene-flow hypothesis is correct, individual winter-annual species should have populations with genetic spatial structures implying short distances of gene flow. To test this idea, we sampled six populations of Eschscholzia parishii (Papaveraceae) in three pairs of watersheds within a 28-km radius in southern California. We quantified genetic diversity and structure and inferred the distance of gene flow in these populations using single nucleotide polymorphisms derived from genotyping-by-sequencing. Estimated distances of gene flow were quite small (σ = 10.4–14.9 m), with strong genetic structure observed within and between populations. Kinship declined steeply with ln distance (r2 = 0.85). Petal size and shape differed significantly between the northernmost and southernmost populations. These findings support the hypothesis that the high diversity of warm-desert winter annuals might result, in part, from genetic differentiation within species at small spatial scales driven by poor seed dispersal.