Genosets for APOE and CYP7A1-rs3808607 variants do not predict LDL cholesterol lowering upon intervention with plant sterols in a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial

Abstract

ABSTRACT Background The consumption of 2 g/d plant sterols (PSs) reduces circulating LDL cholesterol by ≤10%. The degree of LDL cholesterol lowering was associated with specific apolipoprotein E [APOE, Reference SNP (rs)429358] and cholesterol 7α-hydroxylase (CYP7A1, rs3808607) genosets in previous post hoc analyses of randomized controlled trials. However, because post hoc analyses do not conform to the randomization model, there is a greater potential that the findings could be due to type I error, thus warranting validation through an a priori–designed intervention trial. Objectives The GenePredict Plant Sterol study (GPS) was designed to validate associations of LDL cholesterol lowering with specific APOE and CYP7A1 genosets through a priori recruitment of individuals carrying prespecified genosets. Methods A 2-center, double-blind, placebo-controlled, randomized 2-period crossover dietary intervention with 2 g/d PS for 28 d with a minimum 28-d washout was undertaken from July 2017 to December 2019. A priori recruitment of individuals with slightly elevated LDL cholesterol was based on genosets of APOE isoforms and CYP7A1 rs3808607. Randomization was performed with stratification by sex and genoset. Results The recruitment target of 64 participants with prespecified genosets could not be reached, despite the screening of 477 individuals; 42 participants completed the intervention trial. Reductions in LDL cholesterol were similar across all 3 genosets (–0.298 ± 0.164, –0.357 ± 0.115, –0.293 ± 0.109 mmol/L; P = 0.0002 overall; P = 0.9126 for treatment × genoset), providing evidence that the shortfall in recruitment might not have stopped the trial from meeting the objective. Conclusions APOE and CYP7A1 genotypes did not influence the efficacy of LDL cholesterol reductions upon dietary intervention with PSs. Findings of previous post hoc analyses could not be validated in a trial using a priori genotype-based recruitment. Obtaining adequate numbers of participants is challenging in trials using genoset-based recruitment, even for common variants.