Mimicry: just wing it. Wing shape comparison between a mimicking swallowtail and its toxic model

Abstract

Abstract Female eastern tiger swallowtails (Papilio glaucus) are well-known wing coloration mimics of the toxic pipevine swallowtail (Battus philenor). Given that forewing shape is an important component of butterfly flight behaviour found in unpalatable species, we hypothesized that the mimicking females also mimic the forewing shape of their poisonous model. Thus, we predicted that mimicking eastern tiger swallowtails have a more similar wing shape to their model compared with their non-mimicking conspecific morphs. In order to test this, we compared the forewing of the model with mimicking and non-mimicking eastern tiger swallowtail morphs using a standard geometric morphometrics approach. Contrary to our hypothesis, we found significant differences of forewing shape between the two species, with no overlap, regardless of the morph. However, mimicking and non-mimicking female eastern tiger swallowtails were significantly different from each other in wing shape. This indicates that either pleiotropic effects, possibly owing to wing coloration mimicry, or selection for different flight patterns in mimics informed the evolution of forewings in this species. Additionally, we found sexual dimorphism in forewing shape within each species, which supports research indicating that both sexual selection and sex-specific natural selection are important drivers in wing shape evolution.