Substrate- and life habit-induced morphological convergence and divergence in Recent marine bivalve communities

Abstract

Abstract The morphological disparity of the marine benthos, through the Phanerozoic, is shaped by multiple abiotic and biotic factors, among which substrate and ecology are key contributors. However, the relationship among substrate, ecology, and morphology is not straightforward—a substrate can be occupied by phylogenetically unrelated families with different life habits, influencing morphological convergence. In contrast, related taxa may differ in substrate and life habits, indicating morphological divergence. Here we evaluate the effect of substrate and ecology on the community-level morphological disparity of 398 Recent marine bivalve species from coastal India, using geometric morphometrics. We further evaluate whether the observed patterns are decoupled from taxonomic identities, i.e., phylogenetic (in)dependence. We find that the Recent marine bivalve assemblages show significant morphological differences while living in different substrates or having different life habit traits. However, while sharing a specific substrate or life habit trait (tiering/motility), different families do not show shape convergence, i.e., families maintain their mean shape, except for families living in soft sediments, for which they show strong substrate-driven morphological convergence. These instances of morphological divergence and convergence suggest that the association among sediment preference, ecology, and shape can be rather complex, and can often transgress phylogenetic boundaries in bivalves.