A Changed Constitutional Perception of International Law: Demonstrating the Move Ahead With a Turned Back Head?

Abstract

Abstract Russia has entered a new epoch in its attitude to international law by adopting two small amendments to the Constitution. The 2020 Law “On an Amendment to the Constitution of the Russian Federation” introduced a package of numerous modifications. A few key ones deal with international law. Formally, they relate to the very particular issue on the possibility of refusing to comply with the decisions of international jurisdictional bodies, but in essence, they reflect a fundamental change in the country’s attitude to its obligations in the international community and the role of international law in general. The article assesses the significance of these amendments for the Russian legal system and shows the origins of such a change which was first indicated by the decision of the Russian Constitutional Court (RCC) and the federal constitutional law in 2015. Now this change is incorporated into the Constitution. Supporters of the changes are trying to assure that Russia follows the experience of western countries that conduct a similar policy towards the international courts. The article asserts that the argumentation used in such statements is incomplete and inexact; the real situation of relations between western countries and these courts is different. Russia is essentially the only country with an approved position on the acts of international jurisdictional bodies. It is shown that ensuring the supremacy of the Constitution by the amendments is senseless from a legal point of view. The true meaning of them is to erect barriers to “inconvenient” decisions of international bodies. Failure to comply with them entails a violation of obligations under international law. The amendments are to illustrate a demonstrative movement forward, presumably in line with current realities but in fact, this is a movement with a head turned back, a returning to the past. This policy has already become one of logical steps to Russia’s withdrawal from the Council of Europe (CoE).