Affiliation:
1. Bloomsburg University , USA
Abstract
Abstract
In the restoration of art and artifacts there are three salient types of value to consider: relic, aesthetic, and practical. Relic value includes an object’s age, aura, originality, authenticity, and epistemic value. Aesthetic value is connected to how an object looks, sounds, or tastes. Practical value involves whether a thing can be used as designed—whether a book can be read, a building occupied, a car driven. I argue that while these are all legitimate values, it is impossible for a restorer to maximize them all. I conclude that restoration inexorably involves aesthetic choices; there is no supreme value to be maximized and we should be pluralists about the right balance of values. Restoration is like baking a cake; there are many wrong ways to do it, but there are many right ways as well.
Publisher
Oxford University Press (OUP)
Reference28 articles.
1. ‘The phylogeny of The Canterbury Tales’;Barbrook;Nature,1998
2. ‘Reversability: fact or fiction? The dangers of art restoration’;Beck;Source: Notes in the History of Art,1999
3. ‘The work of art in the age of mechanical reproduction’,;Benjamin,1968
4. ‘Theory of restoration, I’,;Brandi,1996