Photoevaporation obfuscates the distinction between wind and viscous angular momentum transport in protoplanetary discs

Abstract

ABSTRACT How protoplanetary discs evolve remains an unanswered question. Competing theories of viscosity and magnetohydrodynamic disc winds have been put forward as the drivers of angular momentum transport in protoplanetary discs. These two models predict distinct differences in the disc mass, radius, and accretion rates over time, that could be used to distinguish them. However that expectation is built on models that do not include another important process – photoevaporation, both internally by the host star and externally by neighbouring stars. In this work we produce numerical models of protoplanetary discs including viscosity, magnetohydrodynamic disc winds, and internal and external photoevaporation. We find that even weak levels of external photoevaporation can significantly affect the evolution of protoplanetary discs, influencing the observable features such as disc radii, that might otherwise distinguish between viscous and wind driven discs. Including internal photoevaporation further suppresses differences in evolution between viscous and wind driven discs. This makes it much more difficult than previously anticipated, to use observations of nearby star forming regions to determine whether discs are viscous or wind driven. Interestingly we find that evolved protoplanetary discs in intermediate FUV environments may be the best cases for differentiating whether they evolve through viscosity or magnetohydrodynamic disc winds. Ultimately this work demonstrates the importance of understanding what are the key evolutionary processes and including as many of those as possible when exploring the evolution of protoplanetary discs.