Adult Gastroenterology Trainees’ Experience of Receiving Feedback on Their Performance of Endoscopy in the Workplace

Abstract

Abstract Background Competency-based gastrointestinal endoscopy training is concerned with outcomes of the learning experience. Feedback allows for trainees to achieve the expected outcomes. However, little is known about trainees’ experience of receiving feedback. Gaining understanding of their experience could help improve feedback practices. The study was conducted to explore what it means for adult gastroenterology trainees to receive feedback on their performance of endoscopy in the workplace. Methods An interpretative phenomenological approach was used. Individual semi-structured interviews were conducted with six trainees from three Canadian adult gastroenterology residency programs. Interviews were audio-recorded and transcribed verbatim for analysis. Analysis was conducted to identify the phenomenological themes across participants’ accounts of lived experience to provide an insight into the meaning of experiencing the studied phenomenon. Findings Three phenomenological themes of experience were identified: taking pauses, negotiating understandings and accepting asymmetry. Taking pauses allowed for participants to receive feedback on their performance of endoscopy. Participants needed to negotiate attending gastroenterologists’ different understandings of gastrointestinal endoscopy while carrying their own whenever feedback was provided. They had to accept the asymmetry between the roles of care provider and learner as well. Discussion The study has captured the uniqueness and the complexity of the lived experience of receiving feedback on the performance of endoscopy in the workplace from the perspective of study participants. The gained understanding of this experience has enabled the authors to suggest how attending gastroenterologists’ feedback practices may be improved.