Shedding light on species boundaries in small endogeic animals through an integrative approach: species delimitation in the centipede Clinopodes carinthiacus (Chilopoda: Geophilidae) in the south-eastern Alps

Abstract

Abstract The investigation of species boundaries in strictly endogeic animals is challenging because they are prone to fine-scale genetic and phenotypic geographical differentiation owing to low dispersal ability. An integrative approach exploiting different sources of information has seldom been adopted in these animals and even more rarely by treating all data sources equally. We investigated species boundaries in the endogeic centipede Clinopodes carinthiacus across the south-eastern Alps by studying genetic and morphological differentiation in a sample of 66 specimens from 27 sites, complemented by the morphological examination of more than 1100 specimens from other sites. Hypotheses of species delimitation were obtained independently from the molecular sequences of three markers (mitochondrial 16S and COI and nuclear 28S) by means of different species discovery methods (automatic barcode gap discovery, assemble species by automatic partitioning, general mixed Yule coalescent and the Poisson tree process) and from ten morphological characters by means of a model-based cluster analysis and Bayesian model selection. We found strong support for the existence of at least two species: C. carinthiacus s.s. and Clinopodes strasseri, which was formerly described as a subspecies of another species, and later placed in synonymy with C. carinthiacus. The two species coexist in syntopy in at least one site.