Job function as determinant of clinker exposure at workplaces during cement production

Abstract

Abstract Objectives In the cement production industry, exposure to airborne particulate matter is associated with a decline in lung function and increased airway symptoms. Exposure to clinker—the major constituent of cement and supposedly the cause of the observed adverse health effects—was determined recently in 15 cement production plants located in 8 different countries (Estonia, Greece, Italy, Norway, Sweden, Switzerland, Spain, Turkey). It was shown that the median clinker abundance in the thoracic fraction varied between approximately 20% and 70% for individual plants. The present study complements the previous work by investigating the significance of job function as a determinant of clinker exposure. Methods The elemental composition (water and acid-soluble fractions separately) of 1,227 personal thoracic workplace samples was analyzed by positive matrix factorization (PMF) to determine the contribution of different sources to the composition of airborne particulate matter and to quantify the clinker content. Results Median thoracic mass air concentrations varied for individual job functions between 0.094 and 12 mg/m3 (estimated separately for different plants). The PMF 5-factor solution yielded median relative clinker abundances in the personal thoracic samples between 7.6% and 81% for individual job functions. Thoracic clinker air concentrations are highest for cleaning, production, and maintenance work, and lowest for administration and other work. Foremen and laboratory personnel show intermediate exposure levels. The plant was found to have a much higher contribution to the total variance of the thoracic clinker air concentrations than the job function. Thoracic clinker air concentrations (medians between 0.01 and 5.5 mg/m3) are strongly correlated with the thoracic mass air concentrations and to a lesser extent with the relative clinker abundance in an aerosol sample. Conclusions Job function is an important predictor of exposure to clinker in the cement production industry. As clinker is suspected to be the causal agent for the observed adverse health effects among cement production workers, the clinker air concentration may be a better exposure metric than thoracic air mass concentration despite the strong correlation between the two. Reduction strategies should focus on the most exposed job categories cleaning, production, and maintenance work.