The Effect of Biomarker Use on the Speed and Duration of Clinical Trials for Cancer Drugs

Abstract

Abstract Background The purpose of this study was to explore the effects biomarkers have on the duration and speed of clinical trials in oncology. Materials and Methods Clinical trial data was pooled from www.clinicaltrials.gov within the 4 cancer indications of non-small cell lung cancer, breast cancer, melanoma, and colorectal cancer. Heatmaps of clinical timelines were used to display differences in the frequency and timing of clinical trials across trials that used or did not use biomarkers, for all 4 indications. Results Screening of 8630 clinical trials across the 4 indications yielded 671 unique drugs corresponding to 1224 eligible trials used in our analysis. The constructed heatmaps visually represented that biomarkers did not have an effect on the time gap between trial phases for non-small cell lung cancer and melanoma but did for colorectal and breast cancer trials, reducing the speed of trial timelines. It was also observed that biomarker trials were more often concurrent over shorter periods of time and began later in the timeline for non-small cell lung and colorectal cancers. Conclusion The novel visualization method revealed longer gaps between trial phases, later clinical trial start times, and shorter periods of concurrently run trials for drugs that used biomarkers. The study highlights that biomarker-driven trials might impact drug approval timelines and need to be considered carefully in clinical development plan.