Review article: Performance assessment of radiation-based field sensors for monitoring the water equivalent of snow cover (SWE)
-
Published:2021-11-04
Issue:11
Volume:15
Page:5079-5098
-
ISSN:1994-0424
-
Container-title:The Cryosphere
-
language:en
-
Short-container-title:The Cryosphere
Author:
Royer Alain,Roy Alexandre,Jutras Sylvain,Langlois Alexandre
Abstract
Abstract. Continuous and spatially distributed data of snow mass (water equivalent of
snow cover, SWE) from automatic ground-based measurements are increasingly
required for climate change studies and for hydrological applications (snow
hydrological-model improvement and data assimilation). We present and
compare four new-generation sensors, now commercialized, that are
non-invasive and based on different radiations that interact with snow for SWE
monitoring: cosmic-ray neutron probe (CRNP), gamma ray monitoring (GMON)
scintillator, frequency-modulated continuous-wave radar (FMCW radar) at 24 GHz and global navigation satellite system (GNSS) receivers (GNSSr). All
four techniques have relatively low power requirements, provide continuous
and autonomous SWE measurements, and can be easily installed in remote
areas. A performance assessment of their advantages, drawbacks and
uncertainties is discussed from experimental comparisons and a literature
review. Relative uncertainties are estimated to range between 9 % and 15 %
when compared to manual in situ snow surveys that are also discussed.
Results show the following. (1) CRNP can be operated in two modes of functioning:
beneath the snow, it is the only system able to measure very deep snowpacks
(> 2000 mm w.e.) with reasonable uncertainty across a wide range
of measurements; CRNP placed above the snow allows for SWE measurements over a
large footprint (∼ 20 ha) above a shallow snowpack. In both cases, CRNP
needs ancillary atmospheric measurements for SWE retrieval. (2) GMON
is the most mature instrument for snowpacks that are typically up to 800 mm w.e. Both CRNP (above snow) and GMON are sensitive to surface
soil moisture. (3) FMCW radar needs auxiliary snow-depth
measurements for SWE retrieval and is not recommended for automatic SWE
monitoring (limited to dry snow). FMCW radar is very sensitive to wet snow,
making it a very useful sensor for melt detection (e.g., wet avalanche
forecasts). (4) GNSSr allows three key snowpack parameters to be
estimated simultaneously: SWE (range: 0–1000 mm w.e.), snow depth and
liquid water content, according to the retrieval algorithm that is used. Its
low cost, compactness and low mass suggest a strong potential for GNSSr
application in remote areas.
Publisher
Copernicus GmbH
Subject
Earth-Surface Processes,Water Science and Technology
Reference106 articles.
1. Alonso, R., del Pozo, J. M. G., Buisaìn, S. T., and Aìlvarez, J. A:
Analysis of the Snow Water Equivalent at the AEMet-Formigal Field Laboratory
(Spanish Pyrenees) during the 2019/2020 winter season using a
Stepped-Frequency Continuous Wave Radar (SFCW), Remote Sens., 13, 616,
https://doi.org/10.3390/rs13040616, 2021. 2. Andreasen, M., Jensen, K. H., Desilets, D., Franz, T., Zreda, M., Bogena,
H., and Looms, M. C.: Status and perspectives of the cosmic-ray neutron
method for soil moisture estimation and other environmental science
applications, Vadose Zone J., 16, 1–11, https://doi.org/10.2136/vzj2017.04.0086, 2017. 3. Appel, F., Koch, F., Rösel, A., Klug, P., Henkel, P., Lamm, M., Mauser,
W., and Bach, H.: Advances in Snow Hydrology Using a Combined Approach of
GNSS In Situ Stations, Hydrological Modelling and Earth Observation – A Case
Study in Canada, Geosciences, 9, 44, https://doi.org/10.3390/geosciences9010044, 2019. 4. Berezovskaya, S. and Kane, D. L.: Strategies for measuring snow water
equivalent for hydrological applications: Part 1, accuracy of measurements.
Proceedings of 16th Northern Research Basin Symposium, Petrozavodsk, Russia,
22–35, 2007. 5. Bissell, V. C. and Peck, E. L.: Monitoring snow water equivalent by using
natural soil radioactivity, Water Resour. Res., 9, 885–890, 1973.
Cited by
9 articles.
订阅此论文施引文献
订阅此论文施引文献,注册后可以免费订阅5篇论文的施引文献,订阅后可以查看论文全部施引文献
|
|