Intercomparison of daytime stratospheric NO₂ satellite retrievals and model simulations

Abstract

Abstract. This paper evaluates the agreement between stratospheric NO2 retrievals from infrared limb sounders (MIPAS and HIRDLS) and solar UV/VIS backscatter sensors (OMI, SCIAMACHY limb and nadir) over the 2005–2007 period and across the seasons. The observational agreement is contrasted with the representation of NO2 profiles in 3-D chemical transport models such as the Whole Atmosphere Community Climate Model (SD-WACCM) and TM4. A conclusion central to this work is that the definition of a reference for stratospheric NO2 columns formed by consistent agreement among SCIAMACHY, MIPAS and HIRDLS limb records (all of which agree to within 0.25 × 1015 molecules cm−2 or better than 10%) allows us to draw attention to relative errors in other datasets, e.g.: (1) the WACCM model overestimates NO2 densities in the extratropical lower stratosphere, particularly over northern latitudes by up to 35% relative to limb observations, and (2) there are remarkable discrepancies between stratospheric NO2 column estimates from limb and nadir techniques, with a characteristic seasonal and latitude dependent pattern. We find that SCIAMACHY nadir and OMI stratospheric columns show overall biases of −0.6 × 1015 molecules cm−2 (−20%) and +0.6 × 10 15 molecules cm−2 (+20%) relative to limb observations. It is highlighted that biases in nadir stratospheric columns are not expected to affect tropospheric retrievals significantly, and that they can be attributed to errors in the total slant column density, either related to algorithmic or instrumental effects. In order to obtain accurate and long time series of stratospheric NO2, a critical evaluation of the currently used Differential Optical Absorption Spectroscopy (DOAS) approaches to nadir retrievals becomes essential, as well as their agreement to limb and ground-based observations, particularly now that limb techniques are giving way to nadir observations as the next generation of climate and air quality monitoring instruments pushes forth.