Physiological flexibility of phytoplankton impacts modelled chlorophyll and primary production across the North Pacific Ocean

Abstract

Abstract. Phytoplankton growth, and hence biomass, responds to variations in light and nutrient availability in the near-surface ocean. A wide variety of models have been developed to capture variable chlorophyll : carbon ratios due to photoacclimation, i.e. the dynamic physiological response of phytoplankton to varying light and nutrient availability. Although photoacclimation models have been developed and tested mostly against laboratory results, their application and testing against the observed flexible response of phytoplankton communities remains limited. Hence, the biogeochemical implications of photoacclimation in combination with ocean circulation have yet to be fully explored. We compare modelled chlorophyll and primary production from an inflexible phytoplankton functional type model (InFlexPFT), which assumes fixed carbon (C) : nitrogen (N) : chlorophyll (Chl) ratios, to that from a recently developed flexible phytoplankton functional type model (FlexPFT), which incorporates photoacclimation and variable C : N : Chl ratios. We couple each plankton model with a 3-D eddy-resolving ocean circulation model of the North Pacific and evaluate their respective performance versus observations (e.g. satellite imagery and vertical profiles of in situ observations) of Chl and primary production. These two models yield different horizontal and vertical distributions of Chl and primary production. The FlexPFT reproduces observed subsurface Chl maxima in the subtropical gyre, although it overestimates Chl concentrations. In the subtropical gyre (where light is sufficient), even at low nutrient concentrations, the FlexPFT yields higher chlorophyll concentrations and faster growth rates, which result in higher primary production in the subsurface, compared to the InFlexPFT. Compared to the FlexPFT, the InFlexPFT yields slower growth rates and lower Chl and primary production. In the subpolar gyre, the FlexPFT also predicts faster growth rates near the surface, where light and nutrient conditions are most favourable. Compared to the InFlexPFT, the key differences that allow the FlexPFT to better reproduce the observed patterns are its assumption of variable, rather than fixed, C : N : Chl ratios and interdependent, rather than strictly multiplicative, effects of light limitation (photoacclimation) and nutrient limitation (uptake). Our results suggest that incorporating these processes has the potential to improve chlorophyll and primary production patterns in the near-surface ocean in future biogeochemical models.