Biodegradable semirigid plate and miniscrew fixation compared with rigid titanium fixation in experimental calvarial osteotomy

Abstract

Object. To determine the biocompatibility and suitability of resorbable plates and miniscrews, consolidation of symmetrical, bilateral frontal bone craniotomies that had been closed using various methods was studied in 20 growing lambs.Methods. Bone fixation with a flexible, punched polylactide plate and four slowly degradable, self-reinforced polylevolactide (SR-PLLA) or rapidly degradable, self-reinforced polyglycolide (SR-PGA) miniscrews (10 animals in each group) was compared intraindividually with rigid fixation by using a titanium miniplate and four miniscrews. Plain x-ray films, magnetic resonance images, histological studies, and histomorphometric studies were obtained at 4 to 104 weeks.Conclusions. No dislocation, instability, clinical foreign body reactions, infections, or loss of fixation were observed. Bone consolidation of the 2.35-mm-wide craniotomy lines was incomplete; connective tissue—filled defects through the bone were observed in 13 of 28 lines at 26 to 52 weeks. Statistical analyses based on histomorphometric studies showed no difference in consolidation with SR-PLLA miniscrew and titanium plate/screw fixation or between the two resorbable fixation methods. Fixation with rapidly degradable SR-PGA miniscrews resulted in less effective consolidation than on the contralateral titanium-treated side (p < 0.05), but the bone segment was thicker (p < 0.005). The SR-PGA miniscrews had disappeared by 6 weeks, the polyactide plate by 104 weeks, and the SR-PLLA miniscrews had been mostly resorbed at 104 weeks. Passive translocation of the titanium plates and screws into the bone tissue was seen at 52 and 104 weeks. In rapidly growing lamb frontal bone, comparable consolidation results, without complications, can be achieved with semirigid resorbable fixation compared with rigid metallic fixation.