Barriers to overlapping complex and general spine surgery at a tertiary academic hospital

Abstract

OBJECTIVE Policy concern and debate surround the concept of overlapping spine surgery. Overlapping surgery specifically refers to nonessential portions of the case or noncutting time overlap. This differs from concurrent surgery, in which critical portions of the procedure overlap. Here the authors explore the barriers for safe and efficient overlapping surgery in academic spinal deformity practice. METHODS Over a 24-month period, cases of spinal deformity, degenerative cases, anterior cervical discectomy and fusions (ACDFs), and laminectomy were reviewed for duration in operating room (OR) prior to surgery, duration of cutting time, duration in OR after surgery, turnover duration, and time delay from initial start time. Standard degenerative cases were referenced as 1–2 ACDFs as well as 1- to 2-level laminectomy surgery. The blocks of time between two consecutive cutting periods were investigated to determine the feasibility of overlapping an additional surgery. Specifically, the authors compared the blocks of time that include the postsurgery period, the turnover period, and the presurgery period to cutting periods. RESULTS One hundred twenty-six complex spinal deformity procedures and 85 degenerative cases (including 49 ACDFs and 36 laminectomies) from one center and one neurosurgeon were reviewed. These procedures were performed between September 2019 and December 2021 with a 3-month gap in military deployment. On average, the procedure’s duration for cases of deformity was 236.5 minutes, for cases of ACDFs it was 84 minutes, and for cases of laminectomies it was 105.5 minutes. The block of noncutting time while the patient was in the OR showed no difference from the surgical cut time. The turnover time between cases was 52.35 minutes. Of 100 cases scheduled as the first case of the day, 94 had a delay to the OR averaging 18.2 minutes. CONCLUSIONS The data in this study indicate that estimates for pre- and postsurgical times alone are not sufficient to allow for overlapping surgery. The average cut-time duration of ACDF was 84 minutes; the average presurgical time for deformity was 68 minutes. This highlights the critical analysis for further examination of optimal scheduling, on-time first start, turnover periods, and the orchestration of all members of the providing team to optimize the cutting time for safe and consistent implementation of overlapping spine surgery.