Accuracy of Smart Scales on Weight and Body Composition: Observational Study (Preprint)

Abstract

Smart scales are increasingly used at home by patients to monitor their body weight and body composition, but scale accuracy has not often been documented.

The goal of the research was to determine the accuracy of 3 commercially available smart scales for weight and body composition compared with dual x-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) as the gold standard.

We designed a cross-sectional study in consecutive patients evaluated for DEXA in a physiology unit in a tertiary hospital in France. There were no exclusion criteria except patient declining to participate. Patients were weighed with one smart scale immediately after DEXA. Three scales were compared (scale 1: Body Partner [Téfal], scale 2: DietPack [Terraillon], and scale 3: Body Cardio [Nokia Withings]). We determined absolute error between the gold standard values obtained from DEXA and the smart scales for body mass, fat mass, and lean mass.

The sample for analysis included 53, 52, and 48 patients for each of the 3 tested smart scales, respectively. The median absolute error for body weight was 0.3 kg (interquartile range [IQR] –0.1, 0.7), 0 kg (IQR –0.4, 0.3), and 0.25 kg (IQR –0.10, 0.52), respectively. For fat mass, absolute errors were –2.2 kg (IQR –5.8, 1.3), –4.4 kg (IQR –6.6, 0), and –3.7 kg (IQR –8.0, 0.28), respectively. For muscular mass, absolute errors were –2.2 kg (IQR –5.8, 1.3), –4.4 kg (IQR –6.6, 0), and –3.65 kg (IQR –8.03, 0.28), respectively. Factors associated with fat mass measurement error were weight for scales 1 and 2 (<i>P</i>=.03 and <i>P</i>&lt;.001, respectively), BMI for scales 1 and 2 (<i>P</i>=.034 and <i>P</i>&lt;.001, respectively), body fat for scale 1 (<i>P</i>&lt;.001), and muscular and bone mass for scale 2 (<i>P</i>&lt;.001 for both). Factors associated with muscular mass error were weight and BMI for scale 1 (<i>P</i>&lt;.001 and <i>P</i>=.004, respectively), body fat for scales 1 and 2 (<i>P</i>&lt;.001 for both), and muscular and bone mass for scale 2 (<i>P</i>&lt;.001 and <i>P</i>=.002, respectively).

Smart scales are not accurate for body composition and should not replace DEXA in patient care.

ClinicalTrials.gov NCT03803098; https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT03803098