Affiliation:
1. Utrecht University
2. University of Twente
3. Technische Universiteit Delft
4. Vrije University Amsterdam
Abstract
This chapter provides a theoretical lens on conceptual disruption. It offers a typology of conceptual disruption, discusses its relation to conceptual engineering, and sketches a programmatic view of the implications of conceptual disruption for the ethics of technology. We begin by distinguishing between three different kinds of conceptual disruptions: conceptual gaps, conceptual overlaps, and conceptual misalignments. Subsequently, we distinguish between different mechanisms of conceptual disruption, and two modes of conceptual change. We point out that disruptions may be induced by technology, but can also be triggered by intercultural exchanges. Conceptual disruptions frequently yield conceptual uncertainty and may call for conceptual and ethical inquiry. We argue that a useful approach to address conceptual disruptions is to engage in conceptual engineering. We outline what conceptual engineering involves and argue that discussions on conceptual disruption and conceptual engineering can benefit from closer integration. In closing, we discuss the relevance of studying conceptual disruption for technology ethics, and point to the promise of this line of research to innovate practical philosophy at large.
Reference45 articles.
1. Babushkina, Dina, and Athanasios Votsis. 2022. ‘Disruption, technology and the question of (artificial) identity’, AI & Ethics, 2: 611–22,
2. Baker, Robert. 2013. Before Bioethics: A History of American Medical Ethics from the Colonial Period to the Bioethics Revolution (New York: Oxford University Press)
3. Patiency is not a virtue: the design of intelligent systems and systems of ethics;Bryson, Joanna J.;Ethics and Information Technology,2018
4. Introduction: A Guided Tour of Conceptual Engineering and Conceptual Ethics;Cappelen, Herman; Plunkett, David,2020
5. Conceptual Ethics I: Conceptual Ethics I;Burgess, Alexis; Plunkett, David;Philosophy Compass,2013