Effects of donor source on transcriptomic profiles of human kidney tissue

Abstract

AbstractNormal human tissue is a critical reference control in biomedical research. However, the type of tissue donor can significantly affect the underlying biology of the samples. We investigated the impact of tissue donor source type by performing transcriptomic analysis on healthy kidney tissue from three donor source types: cadavers, organ donors, and normal‐adjacent tissue from surgical resections of clear cell renal cell carcinomas, and we compared the gene expression profiles to those of clear cell renal cell carcinoma samples. Comparisons among the normal samples revealed general similarity, with notable differences in gene expression pathways involving immune system and inflammatory processes, response to extracellular stimuli, ion transport, and metabolism. When compared to tumors, the transcriptomic profiles of the normal adjacent tissue were highly similar to the profiles from cadaveric and organ donor tissue samples, arguing against the presence of a field cancerization effect in clear cell renal cell carcinoma. We conclude that all three normal source types are suitable for reference kidney control samples, but important differences must be noted for particular research areas and tissue banking strategies.