Griseofulvin Only Modestly Diminishes Persistence of Trichophyton tonsurans on the Scalp of Carriers

Abstract

OBJECTIVES Using genetic strain typing, we previously identified a high rate of T. tonsurans carriage among preschool-aged children attending an urban daycare center. No treatment was provided as part of the observational study; however, children when symptomatic were treated in accordance with daycare policies. This retrospective investigation examines antifungal drug therapy received during the previous investigation and characterizes the impact of treatment on persistence of the fungus on the scalp.METHODS Children in whom serial typeable isolates of T. tonsurans were recovered were eligible for evaluation. Clinic charts were reviewed and dispensing records obtained from the primary pharmacies serving the daycare. Infection patterns were examined before and after treatment.RESULTS We identified 72 dispensing records for 53 children, all of whom received griseofulvin. Nine children could not be evaluated because treatment was coincident with their last study visit. Thus, 63 treatment events in 44 children with 331 discrete infection events remained. After a single course of griseofulvin, 22.7% of children became culture negative, 6.8% acquired another strain of T. tonsurans and, 70.5% remained persistently positive with the same strain carried prior to treatment. Among those receiving a second course of therapy, 54% remained positive and the cumulative percent of children that became culture negative increased to 36.4%. If children subsequently acquiring a different strain are considered together with those that became culture negative, cumulative strain clearance was observed in 43% of children. Neither the griseofulvin dose nor the duration of time over which children were infected prior to treatment differed between those that remained positive and those that became negative.CONCLUSIONS Griseofulvin eradicates dermatophyte scalp carriage in less than one-half of preschool-aged children receiving between one and four 4-week courses of the drug.