Costs of Weaning Failure: A Prospective, Multicentre, Controlled, Non-Randomised, Interventional Study on Economic Implications for the German Health Care System

Abstract

Background: Intensive care patients with respiratory failure often need invasive mechanical ventilation (IMV). With increasing population age and multimorbidity, the number of patients who cannot be weaned from IMV rises as well. Up to 85% of these patients have no access to a certified weaning centre. Their medical care is associated with impaired quality of life and high costs for the German health care system. Objectives: This study examined the weaning outcome of patients in certified weaning centres after a primarily unsuccessful weaning attempt in order to calculate saving expenses compared to patients on long-term IMV in an outpatient setting. Methods: In this multicentre, controlled, non-randomised, interventional, prospective study, 61 patients (16 from out-of-hospital long-term IMV, 49 from other hospitals) were referred to a certified weaning centre for a second weaning phase. The incurred costs after 1 year of the latter were compared to insurance claim data of patients who were discharged from an acute hospital stay to receive IMV in an outpatient setting. Results: In the intervention group, 50 patients (82%) could be completely weaned or partially weaned using non-invasive ventilation, thus not needing IMV any longer. The costs per patient for weaning and out-of-hospital care in the intervention group were EUR 114,877.08, and the costs in the comparison cohort were EUR 234,442.62. Conclusions: Early transfer to a certified weaning centre can increase weaning success and reduce total costs by approximately EUR 120,000 per patient in the first year. Given the existing structural prerequisites in Germany, every patient should have access to a weaning centre before being transferred to long-term IMV, from a medical and health economical point of view.