A Core Outcome Set for Children With Feeding Tubes and Neurologic Impairment: A Systematic Review

Abstract

CONTEXT: Uncertainty exists about the impacts of feeding tubes on neurologically impaired children. Core outcome sets (COS) standardize outcome selection, definition, measurement, and reporting. OBJECTIVE: To synthesize an evidence base of qualitative data on all outcomes selected and/or reported for neurologically impaired children 0 to 18 years living with gastrostomy/gastrojejunostomy tubes. DATA SOURCES: Medline, Embase, and Cochrane Register databases searched from inception to March 2014. STUDY SELECTION: Articles examining health outcomes of neurologically impaired children living with feeding tubes. DATA EXTRACTION: Outcomes were extracted and assigned to modified Outcome Measures in Rheumatology 2.0 Filter core areas; death, life impact, resource use, pathophysiological manifestations, growth and development. RESULTS: We identified 120 unique outcomes with substantial heterogeneity in definition, measurement, and frequency of selection and/or reporting: “pathophysiological manifestation” outcomes (n = 83) in 79% of articles; “growth and development” outcomes (n = 13) in 55% of articles; “death” outcomes (n = 3) and “life impact” outcomes (n = 17) in 39% and 37% of articles, respectively; “resource use” outcomes (n = 4) in 14%. Weight (50%), gastroesophageal reflux (35%), and site infection (25%) were the most frequently reported outcomes. LIMITATIONS: We were unable to investigate effect size of outcomes because quantitative data were not collected. CONCLUSIONS: The paucity of outcomes assessed for life impact, resource use and death hinders meaningful evidence synthesis. A COS could help overcome the current wide heterogeneity in selection and definition. These results will form the basis of a consensus process to produce a final COS.