A Qualitative Exploration of the Impact of a Distressed Family Member on Pediatric Resuscitation Teams

Abstract

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Family presence during resuscitation (FPDR) is commonplace in many hospitals today. Research has supported the positive effects it can have on family members; however, there is little research about how it may affect the resuscitation team’s performance, especially in a pediatric population. Our objective was to identify how resuscitation team members perceive and respond to the presence of a distressed family member during a resuscitation. METHODS: This is a qualitative study in which we examine FPDR-related themes raised by pediatric resuscitation team members after a resuscitation simulation. As part of a team training educational intervention, pediatric resuscitation teams, composed of nurses, respiratory therapists, and resident physicians, participated in a video-recorded simulated event in which they attempted to resuscitate an infant. During the scenario, a confederate actor played the role of a distressed “parent.” Video-recorded debriefs occurred immediately after each simulation. Video recordings were transcribed verbatim, and then transcripts were coded and analyzed via thematic analysis to saturation. RESULTS: Thirteen postevent video debriefs were analyzed. A total of 74 participants took part in these simulations and debriefs. Analysis revealed 15 major and 29 minor themes, which were mapped to 5 factors, namely resuscitation environment, affective responses, cognitive responses, behavioral responses, and team dynamics. CONCLUSIONS: FPDR has an impact on resuscitation team members’ responses and influences their adaptive behavior. If not managed well, this may pose potential patient safety concerns. Policy and training of specific teamwork skills are ways in which we can better equip health care providers to effectively manage FPDR.