Developing a Methodology for Model Intercomparison and Its Application to Improve Simulated Streamflow by Land Surface Models

Abstract

Abstract Runoff generated by land surface models (LSMs) is extensively used to predict future river discharge under global warming. However, the structural bias of LSMs, the precipitation bias of the climate model, and other factors could cause the runoff to be biased. A model intercomparison study can help understand LSM behavior. Traditional model intercomparison can discover output variation and evaluate performance, but explaining the reason for the difference is challenging. This study developed a novel method to identify the reasons for disparities and suggest improvements. Consequently, we investigated the impacts of model settings by adopting the settings of another model in one model until it can mimic similar features in its output. Hence, we developed a process called the “emulation model.” We employed two LSMs [Simple Biosphere with Urban Canopy (SiBUC) and Meteorological Research Institute Simple Biosphere model (MRI-SiB)] in the Thai River basin. SiBUC produced a higher surface runoff than MRI-SiB, and the development of the MRI-SiB emulation revealed the cause of this variation. The differences in runoff characteristics affected streamflow estimation. For instance, the SiBUC peak discharge was faster and higher than observed in the dry year. Conversely, there was a tendency to underestimate the flow estimated by MRI-SiB runoff during the transition from dry to wet seasons. Incorporating other model settings can alleviate the shortcomings of each model. Overall, the proposed method can identify the strengths and weaknesses of a model and enhance the reproducibility of the hydrological characteristics of the observed discharge in the basin. Significance Statement This study aims to develop a new methodology for model intercomparison to identify the reasons for model output variation. Understanding why models behave differently is important to enhancing the reliability of model prediction. Our findings guide what affects disparities in land surface model runoff-based streamflow estimation, which will help reduce the uncertainty of future flood and drought predictions.