Trailing Horizontal Vortices in Observed and Numerically Simulated Tornadoes

Abstract

Abstract High-resolution numerical simulations of supercell storms reveal complex distributions of vorticity in the vicinity of tornadoes, especially when visualized in three dimensions. As in the simulations, quasi-horizontal vortices (HVs) are occasionally observed near tornadoes, as condensation tubes wrapping around the tornadoes. In this study, visual observations of a violent tornado and visualizations of a high-resolution simulation based on the same tornado case are combined to document distinct HV structures, which trail the tornado very close to the ground toward its right flank (with respect to the tornado’s forward motion), hereafter referred to as “trailing HVs.” The analysis shows that trailing HVs are larger and stronger than HVs typically observed around tornadoes. Still, their sense of rotation matches that of other documented HVs, which is consistent with vorticity generation by surface drag and/or baroclinic torques along internal boundaries of relatively warm rear-flank downdrafts. Interestingly, trailing HVs may display smaller spiral vortices circulating their periphery, which can evolve into more complex structures. Visualizations of three-dimensional vorticity show that the trailing HVs are organized through entanglement of large and small HVs along nearby rear-flank internal boundaries. The internal boundaries also serve as focus for along-boundary stretching of vorticity that becomes mostly streamwise at the location of the trailing HV, resulting in HV strengthening. The spiral vortices are associated with the same entangling processes responsible for the parent (larger) trailing HV structure. Moreover, the analysis suggests that trailing HVs may reinforce the surface wind speeds on the right flank of the tornado.