Abstract 16046: Conventional versus Right Mini-thoracotomy versus Robotic Mitral Valve Replacement/repair; Insights From a Network Meta-analysis

Abstract

Background: Benefits and risks of minimally invasive cardiac surgery (MICS) through right mini-thoracotomy and robotic surgery for mitral valve are not fully understood. We conducted a network meta-analysis comparing the perioperative and long-term outcomes of mitral valve surgery via conventional sternotomy, MICS and robot. Methods: MEDLINE and EMBASE were searched through March 15th, 2020 to identify randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and propensity-score matched (PSM) trials that investigated perioperative and long-term outcomes after mitral surgery via conventional sternotomy, MICS and robot. Subanalyses were conducted by restricting trials, in which mitral valve repair was tried first for all patients. Results: Our systematic literature search identified 2 RCTs and 21 PSM trials. MICS was related to significant decrease in PM ([RR] [95% confidence interval [CI] =0.56 [0.40-0.78]] and SSI (RR [95%CI] =0.53 [0.33-0.85) compared to conventional sternatomy. Re-exploration for bleeding was significantly higher in robot compared to sternotomy (RR [95% CI] =1.56 [1.03-2.37]), and transfusion was higher in sternotomy compared to MICS (RR [95%CI] =1.63 [1.27-2.08]). No significant differences were observed in perioperative mortality, MI, stroke, and LCOS among there procedures. Similarly, there were no significant differences in long-term survival and mitral valve reoperation. Suanalyses by restricting trials in which mitral valve repair tried first for all patients showed MICS was related to significant increase in mitral valve reoperation compared to conventional sternotomy (hazard ratio [95%CI] =7.33 [1.54-34.97]) (Figure). Conclusion: Our network meta-analysis demonstrated similar long-term survival and mitral valve reoperation. However, MICS was related to significant increase in mitral valve reoperation after mitral valve repair compared to conventional sternotomy.